Skip to content

Gevrey Chambertin & Chambolle Musigny from Philippe Leclerc: I have tasted no better red Burgundies

2010 February 22
by cth


  Philippe in his tasting room, which he designed himself.

These pinnacle Pinot Noirs will thrill you every time you uncork them:

2006 Gevrey-Chambertin Premier Cru La Combe aux Moines
2006 Gevrey-Chambertin Premier Cru les Cazetiers
2006 Chambolle-Musigny les Babillaires

Allen Meadows of Burghound reports on Leclerc’s Chambolle Musigny:

2006 Chambolle-Musigny Les Babillières: “A touch of wood spice frames the very ripe yet fresh earthy red raspberry, cranberry and cherry fruit nose where the concentrated, rich, round and sweet flavors are also very firmly structured and the style is clearly old school. Built to age as this is serious but well-balanced. Patience required.”

Chambolle Musigny, wine with an “electric gout de terroir” is an appellation south of Morey St Denis and north of Vougeot on the extraordinary, incomparable Cote d’Or which yields the finest expression of Pinot Noir in the world.

What does a Chambolle Musigny taste like? I’ll let Matt Kramer of Wine Spectator answer that one:

“Chambolle Musigny makes wines of grace. Their power derives not from mass but from a coordination of flavor with finesse: a kind of vinous jujitsu…there should always be underlying strength, even in cummune-level Chambolle-Musigny. It’s too easy to confuse lightness with deftness. A good Chambolle Musigny at whatever level should have backbone; one should be able to readily sense forceful flavor and see both structure and fruit.”

Chambolle Musigny has more limestone in its soil than other appellations in the Cote d’Or and this determines the weight of the wine and its unique fruit signature. You have to get to know Chambolle Musigny and I would start with this one.

Here is what Allen Meadows of Burghound says about Leclerc’s Gevrey-Chambertin:

“2006 Gevrey-Chambertin Combe Aux Moines: An expressive nose that is also trimmed in a bit of oak influence features a panoply of complex red fruit aromas that are slightly more elegant and notably pure that dissolve into round, detailed and rich flavors that display subtle minerality on the precise, firm and nicely focused finish. This is less powerful than the Cazetiers but it’s actually more persistent and less obviously rustic. Rated 90/2016+”

2006 Gevrey-Chambertin les Cazetiers: “A pungent nose combines wood spice and very ripe dark, black and cassis berry fruit aromas where the ripeness continues onto the extremely rich, earthy and animale-infused big-bodied flavors that are chewy, concentrated and serious and culminate in a mouth coating and very powerful finish that is overtly rustic. Rated 90/2016+”

I’ve never had better Gevrey-Chambertin, make that Burgundy, than Leclerc’s Gevrey Chambertin. Philippe’s Premiers Crus are at the Grand Cru level ( at half the price). Philippe is a driven superstar winemaker who produces muscular, concentrated beauties aged over two years in new oak that will make you a Burgundy addict.

I have always felt that Philippe must have some sort of “in” with Mother Nature because there is virtually nothing she can hurl at the Cote d’Or that stumps him in the least. Year in and year out, he pulls off magnificent wines when others stumble.

Philippe’s wines are never fined or filtered. Philippe is such a perfectionist, he’s always busy reaching for that next rung of quality – never completely satisfied with his efforts. There is always something new with which to experiment, but I know he is much, much too hard on himself; his red wines come as close to perfection as I’ve ever had in Burgundy. Don’t miss a chance to experience these wonderful expressions of all that the Cote de Nuits can deliver. Cynthia Hurley

One Response leave one →
  1. Big Jim Slade permalink
    July 18, 2011

    Wow. I didn’t know Barry Gibb was now making wine! First disco, now this – hats off to him :-)

    Seriously, though, sounds like great wine. Hopefully one day I will either have the money or the luck to drink enough Burgundies to know the differences between a Gevrey Chambertin and a Chambolle Musigny. Though I did get to visit this winery on a short tour: http://www.writethefirsttime.com/wine_women_wrongs.htm
    That write up doesn’t even mention their tax troubles – most of their profit went into taxes for 7 years because their parents died unexpectedly (and within about a month of each other) and hadn’t set up ways around the estate tax! Anyway, their premier cru (I think it was “La Dominode”) was lovely and elegant, but finished with a touch of spiciness which really made it. We were given a tasting (this was in 2003) in the tiny cellar of their house by one of the sisters, who for all the world looked like she should be playing volleyball on a beach in California.

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS